Skip to main content

Nonfiction Review: The Family Romanov: Murder, Rebellion, and the Fall of Imperial Russia


Bibliographic-
Fleming, Candace. The Family Romanov: Murder, Rebellion, and the Fall of
Imperial Russia. Schwartz & Wade, 2014. ISBN 978-0-375-86782-8

Summary / Critical analysis-
Candace Fleming brings this already fascinating story to life in a simple but captivating format
for young readers. The history of the Romanov family is told in appropriate detail and creates
the perfect amount of background information leading to their ultimate deaths, and the
mystery surrounding their burials. Anyone who has seen the animated movie Anastasia will
be surprised at the even more exciting true story behind it.


The absurd wealth of Imperial Russia is set against primary-source material from the poor,
working class that also existed at the time. This juxtaposition shows the tensions that were
building at the time, and serve as a reminder that not all history is the flashy dramatic kind.


Fleming draws readers into the story from page one, and explains things that may be unknown
(lines of succession, Russian names, etc) at a high level that is clear and unpatronizing.
Quotes and dialogue are integrated seamlessly and only add to the overall narrative. This
text reads like a novel and is just as entertaining. The design of the book makes reading by
section or chapter easy, and the use of a slightly larger font makes the volume of
information much less intimidating.


A family tree and map of Russia appear at the beginning of the book, and a bibliography,
chapter notes, and further reading / online sources list will help readers find more information
on this insane story. I recommend doing some research into the more recent forensics
being done on the remains of the Romanov family, as this is still ongoing.

Awards and Review Excerpts-


Sibert Honor
Orbis Pictus Award
Golden Kite Award
NCSS/CBC Notable Social Studies Trade Book
LA Times Book Prize


“Award-winning author Fleming crafts an exciting narrative from this complicated history
and its intriguing personalities. It is full of rich details about the Romanovs, insights into
figures such as Vladimir Lenin and firsthand accounts from ordinary Russians affected by
the tumultuous events.” Kirkus Reviews, 2014

“Compulsively readable, Fleming's artful work of narrative history is splendidly researched
and documented. For readers who regard history as dull, Fleming's extraordinary book is
proof positive that, on the contrary, it is endlessly fascinating, absorbing as any novel, and
the stuff of an altogether memorable reading experience.” Book List Online, 2014


Connections-
  • National Geographic video about the death of the Romanov family:
https://www.nationalgeographic.com.au/videos/mystery-files/the-death-of-the-romanovs-4528.aspx
  • Compare facts to the animated movie Anastasia: What did they get right? Why do you think they did not tell the true story instead?

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Review: Wolf in the Snow

Wolf in the Snow 1. Bibliographic: Cordell, Matthew. Wolf in the Snow. New York: Feiwell and Friends, 2017. ISBN 978-1-250-07636-6 2. Summary: A young girl and a wolf pup set off on their own paths through the snow, only to end up lost , together. The girl helps the wolf find its family, eventually becoming too tired to find her own way home. The wolf pack returns to help her reunite with her family. 3. Critical analysis: Illustrations of a brave girl in a red coat traveling through a snowstorm tell a story of compassion between herself and a young wolf. Only a few onomatopoeias are used to indicate feeling or plot points, but the expressiveness of the girl’s eyes and her body language convey most of the meaning. The facing page layouts done in ink and watercolor are powerful, particularly when the girl and the mother wolf come face to face. This 2018 Caldecott winning story is wonderful to sit and read with a child or two, but would be challenging to convey i...

Historical Fiction: Between Shades of Gray

Sepetys, Ruta. Between Shades of Gray. Philomel Books, 2011.     ISBN 978-0399254123 Plot summary/ critical analysis 1941, Lithuania: Lina and her family are taken by the Soviets in the middle of the night. They are separated from Lina’s father and taken to train cars that will eventually take them and other Lithuanians, Estonians, and Latvians to Soviet labor camps. Lina takes every opportunity to draw, finding both a release and purpose; she hopes that her drawing will make their way to her father so they can be found and rescued. Lina manages to form relationships with other prisoners, even falling in love at one point. Underneath all the trauma is a story of continuing to have hope and to fight even when it’s hard. Sepetys tackles the trauma and confusion in a straightforward way. It is depressing and necessary storytelling of a time in history that was covered up and ignored for decades. The descriptions are vivid and heartbreaking; you...

Traditional Lit. Review: The Three Little Javelinas

The Three Little Javelinas by Susan Lowell and Jim Harris 1. Bibliographic- Lowell, Susan. The Three Little Javelinas. Ill. by Jim Harris. Arizona: Rising Moon, 1992. ISBN 0-87358-542-9 2. Summary- Three sibling javelinas (southwestern relative of pigs) set off on their own journeys to live life and make a home in the southwest desert. As each sibling attempts to build their homes - one of tumbleweeds, one of saguaros ribs, and the other of adobe- a trickster coyote follows them, trying to get a good meal. The coyote destroys the first two javelinas’ homes, and they run to their sister’s adobe brick house. Together they withstand the coyote’s attack, and send him howling into the desert. 3. Critical analysis- A twist on the classic three little pigs, the Three Little Javelinas teaches about patience, cleverness, and perseverance of the siblings running from a coyote. This tale is set in the Sonoran desert, and it moves quickly in its descriptions of t...